Published Benicia Herald May 30, 2004

Home design in earthquake country
By Steve McKee

It’s sort of a rite of passage as a Californian to experience your first earthquake. My twelve year old has one under her belt. It was the Napa quake of a few years ago and we both felt it because we were sitting still in the front room together. The house swayed a couple of times and I of course began to excitedly jabber on about what had just happened.

Though often just a brief and fun diversion, these quakes have the potential to get really big and become a life shattering event. Just ask the good people living in those big blocky stucco apartment buildings in Northridge and the San Fernando Valley ten years ago when a sizable earthquake hit.

A friend of my dad’s was in Anchorage in 1964 when hell broke loose. It was horrible, he says. The thing about the Alaska quake was that it was not only big (roughly twice as strong as the Bay Area quake of 1989) but it was long, terribly long, four minutes long. The houses were jerked back and forth. . . . . and it just kept going on and on. Most earthquakes are well under a minute.

In Benicia we’re close enough to major earthquake faults such as the San Andreas and the Hayward fault to be at risk for damage when “the big one” hits. We have our own more local faults such as the Concord – Green Valley fault, but they’re considered “minor faults” without as much risk for major movement.

When the Loma Prieta earthquake (“the pretty big one”) occurred in October of ’89, Benicia shook enough that our downtown fire department building got condemned, even though the earthquake was centered in a fairly distant piece of the San Andreas fault south of San Jose.

The good news about all of this earthquake stuff is that structures are now being built with some really good engineering in them. Engineers swarm over the damaged areas after a quake has hit to see what failed and why. One of the lessons learned from the Northridge quake of ‘94 was the importance of having really strong washers at the foundation bolts, among other things. That’s right, something as simple as making the washers on the bolts bigger and stronger would help many structures survive a quake like that one (which had an unusually destructive up and down motion compared to most earthquakes. This was due to the fact that the Northridge fault was a horizontal one, so that the pieces of earth sliding by each other created a sort of jack hammer motion.)

Over the years California designers and builders have gotten pretty good at dealing with seismic engineering. Framers have come to know earthquake hardware and techniques like builders elsewhere know hammers and nails. Words like “Shear nailing” and “stab bolts” and “HD5A’s” are the language of the California job site.

How houses resist earthquakes:

When a house is being framed and before it gets siding, it will get largely covered in plywood that is nailed on very tightly along the edges. This plywood turns a framed wall into a “shear wall” and it’s the heart and soul of earthquake design. The plywood prevents the wall from bending or racking in the direction parallel to the length of the wall. These plywood shear walls need to be helped by steel connectors designed to connect the ends of the shear walls to the foundations. When strategically placed in various locations around the house, these shear walls will take the “whiplash” energy that occurs in an earthquake and transfer it through these rigid wall connections into the ground.

What’s nifty about these shear walls is that after the house is finished, you don’t even know they’re there. They’re invisibly distributed throughout your house, disguised as regular walls.

I had someone tell me once he thought houses should sway to counteract the earthquake forces. Wrong! Sheetrock joints don’t do well in swaying houses. Windows don’t like the swaying motion either. When it comes to earthquakes, we want our houses to be rigid unwavering wooden rocks.

Local house mover Phil Joy told me about a builder friend of his who was at a job site when the Loma Prieta quake hit. The house was about half finished and had recently had its framing sheared with plywood, so the house did just fine. The builder happened to touch the edge of a shear wall and all the nails were very warm to the touch. The nails had absorbed the energy of the earthquake’s motion and transformed it into heat! Here was tactile proof you could feel as a warm glow at your fingertips of the energy transfer that I usually just encounter inside some long math problem. I love that story.

To engineer a house for earthquakes (or “lateral loads”) is to complete several pages of technical calculations based on a variety of factors, all mandated by building codes. Proximity to earthquake faults is factored in, as well as soil type, and many other fairly arcane elements. Because lateral loads include wind forces, a house is also examined for wind loads. The loads created by “worst case” wind storms are compared to the lateral loads created by earthquakes to see which one is stronger. Sometimes the wind force is deemed stronger, even in earthquake country. It has to do with how “thick” the house is, to put it very simply. (Extreme example to make the point: a billboard is more susceptible to wind force than earthquake force.)

With all this considered, the resulting force numbers are applied (on paper) sideways to the house and distributed into the various shear walls that are located throughout the house. If your architect had good foresight, there will be nice pieces of walls located at strategic places ready to become shear walls with the mere addition of a plywood skin and some earthquake bolts. If your architect or designer wasn’t so hot, there will be hair pulling and angst late in the design phase and maybe some extreme engineering to try and make the house comply with modern earthquake codes. I heard about one remodel where the homeowner learned after their drawings were completed that their vintage kitchen was going to need to be gutted to make way for shear plywood.

As a homeowner you shouldn’t have to learn about all this earthquake stuff in detail. You should at least know why you can’t have only windows along a face of the house. Having said that, I feel the need to tell you that there actually is a way to have all windows, but that it involves big bucks and a heavy duty steel framework that usually requires a crane to lift it into place. But that’s another story, for another day.

Current Edition:
June 23, 2010 - Confessions of a Lighting Junky

Archive:
2010
May 25, 2010 - A Day in the Life of the Architecture Student
May 4, 2010 - Job Site Tips I Learned the Hard Way
March 25, 2010 - More Than Just a Pretty Picture
February 18, 2010 - A Benicia Sense of Place
January 27, 2010 - Aging in place

2009
December 24, 2009 - Why we travel: the hidden Puerto Vallarta is there for the taking
December 1, 2009 - Paradise stolen: greed and redemption on the Mayan Riviera
October 25, 2009 - The new rules for downtown
September 20, 2009 - Ongoing adventures in city life
August 23, 2009 - How to almost miss out on architecture school
August 2, 2009 - Visiting Italy in the movies
June 26, 2009 - Secret weapons of design
May 24, 2009 - Germany, the war, and why we like life in Benicia
April 23, 2009 - A hundred and sixty years in Benicia
March 12, 2009 - On dream houses in Mexico and life lessons
February 15, 2009 - Building a House in Mexico - the Reality

January 15, 2009 - Phil Joy's house move enters the home stretch

2008
December 26, 2008 - Fireplaces: New Rules
November 27, 2008 - A Benician in L.A.
October 22, 2008 - Why I'm Doing My Addition Now
September 17, 2008 - Why We Travel
August 20, 2008 - Americans in Paris
July 30, 2008 - Front Porch City
May 30, 2008 - On turning fifty, crescent moons, and Frank Lloyd Wright
April 22, 2008 - Building green, getting real
March 27, 2008 - Benicia versus the country club
February 27, 2008 - Stone arches totally rock
January 23, 2008 - These are a few of your favorite things
January 6, 2008 - Another vintage house is delivered to Benicia


2007
December 16, 2007 - How First Street keeps us together
November 22, 2007 - You, the tile shop, the decision
October 23, 2007 - A Benician in New York
September 19, 2007 - Figuring out how much your building project will cost
August 21, 2007 - Why we travel: The city of Prague is a marvel – who knew?
July 22, 2007 - The “it” moment with my new house
June 20, 2007 - Dreamhouse for rent
May 20, 2007 - Artist Open Studios Reveal Creative Undercurrent Alive in Benicia
March 2, 2007 - Haiku Moments and Performance Art in the Comfort of Your Own Home
April 22, 2007 - Once in a Lifetime Adventure: Say Yes
January 28, 2007 - Countertops: We Live in a Stone Age

2006
December 31, 2006 - The Day the Thompson-Joy House Came to Town
December 3, 2006 - The Revenge of Unpaid Carpenters (And Other True Stories)
October 29, 2006 - A House Move for the Ages
September 24, 2006 - My Best Five Seconds at Design School
August 17, 2006 - Getting Bids: "The Rules"
July 23, 2006 - Benicia's Growth Rings
June 18, 2006 - The Well-considered Window Seat
May 14, 2006 - Hearst Castle - Residential Design Mind Blower
April 16, 2006 - San Francisco April 1906: Ordinary People in Extraordinary Times
March 17, 2006 - Dog Handling at the Ititarod

February 12, 2006 - Your House's Defense Against Rising Energy Costs
January 8 , 2006 - Not Your Father's Living Room

2005
December 12, 2005 - The Best Design Book Ever
September 23, 2005 - Further Adventures in the Eternal city
August 28, 2005 - Lessons from Rome
July 31, 2005 - Roadside at the Tour de France
June 9, 2005 - My Accidental Getaway Room
May 8, 2005 - Lighting Basics: It's the layers
April 10, 2005 - Architecture School: The Reality
March 13, 2005 - Southampton Concrete Slab Floors: What's to Know
Jan. 30, 2005 - Some Basics to Know Before You Build

2004
Dec. 26, 2004 - News Flash: Good builders earn their money
Nov. 14, 2004 - The Wonderful Failure That is Benicia
Sept. 26, 2004 - Energy Laws and Your Building Project
August 14, 2004 - Architecture Goes to the Movies
July 11, 2004 - What's Really Up with a 2nd Floor Addition
May 30, 2004 - Home Design in Earthquake Country
May 2, 2004 - Sightlines Make a Huge Impact
April 11, 2004 - Meeting of the Minds in Your Design
March 21, 2004 - Welcome to the New Column